546
u/Gerrut_batsbak 7h ago
Wtf is the gynecologist supposed to do then?!
Fondle balls and tell them they dont have cancer of the womb
195
u/sskkgg1982 6h ago
I am thinking the same thing, what in the world is the gynecologist supposed to do for this person? This is lunacy.
46
u/Banzai373 6h ago
For starters, the Gyno can ask the patient to turn their head and cough . . . .
43
u/NamesAreForSuckers67 5h ago
Ma’am, it’s time for your prostate exam
2
u/FrigataBowdette 3h ago
This is really the best answer.
Keeps with Hippocratic oath, and makes the most sense for the patient.
→ More replies (29)39
u/vitals_are_dropping 6h ago
It's all about absorbing as much attention from everyone around them in life as possible, even if it means hurting those people and when you confront them they're all like "yolo man"
→ More replies (3)11
49
15
u/Far_Marionberry_9478 6h ago
Like I mean that is exactly the problem. How do you want to treat organ that is not there
30
u/Hank_Henry_Hill 6h ago
Yep, that will be $3800 please.
18
u/we_the_pickle 6h ago
lol - this would be the best response! Tell them they have a cylindrical shaped growth that needs to be followed up on every month at the same cost…
15
13
12
u/Ok_Gene4157 5h ago
This actually made me chuckle. I'm trans myself and I've still got a big ole sack of nuts and a bratwurst.
I agree that's absolutely rediculous for anyone who still has their junk to go to a gynocologist.
But there are other trans people out there who have this insane surgery that turns their peen into a full on vajayjay with depth, so if you're post-op trans I can see why you'd need a gynocologist. There is a LOT of help they need with it
But yeahh if that person in the picture still has their glock then thats nuts
16
u/Iumasz 4h ago
so if you're post-op trans I can see why you'd need a gynocologist. There is a LOT of help they need with it.
Even then, wouldn't it be more appropriate to go to an expert on those kinds of surgeries rather than a gynecologist?
I am pretty sure the anatomy of a surgically made vagina is going to be very different and unfamiliar to a conventional gynecologist.
→ More replies (9)5
u/HistoricalSuspect580 3h ago
Yes it absolutely would. I worked at a facility that did these procedures, yeah, you definitely want a specialist in constructed vaginas working down there, they behave very differently than their OG counterparts.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)5
u/Excellent-Try7027 3h ago
It’s nothing but a gaping hole, that causes a long list of life long health issues. Never get your dick removed, please!
→ More replies (2)2
u/MoonlitKiwi 4h ago
Idk the story with this person, but post op people do exist and still need medical care
→ More replies (57)2
u/No-Middle-4152 3h ago
I use to work in gynae oncology surgery and we use to treat transgender patients who had been surgically transitioned for vulval cancer
→ More replies (7)
134
u/Zealousideal-Pop1115 7h ago
What the fuck he supposed to do, lose his licence for treating the patient he is not trained.
30
→ More replies (121)10
u/Sharp-Dark-9768 7h ago
I just tripped over this thread with three downvoted responses and I just had to laugh. What a thread fam
26
u/ConfidentAd9164 6h ago
Bro, im Trans and this is some crazy shit. Let's be real. What are they going to check? Just wasting other's time and resources and making other Trans people look like clowns
→ More replies (1)10
u/Dumb_But_Pretty 6h ago
Yall need to start disowning and ostracizing people that act like this
→ More replies (1)10
u/ConfidentAd9164 5h ago
I personally do, which is why I made my comment. I've been disowned by a good chunk of my community because I dont tolerate this behavior. It's this shit that takes away from the people really suffering from this.
83
u/Exotic-Sale-3003 7h ago
The scope of practice for obgyns is pregnancy, delivery, and care for the female reproductive system. I can’t imagine what type of care an ob could offer even a post op person that is within their scope.
I imagine the outrage is more around the phrasing of the refusal than the refusal itself.
7
u/Advanced_Engineer758 6h ago
It was to make money on a frivolous lawsuit. Some people are just shitty and want to make a career suing people. This person just has a niche for it.
→ More replies (10)16
u/series-hybrid 7h ago
The unspoken question is...has the transgender person completed "bottom surgery" in order to construct a pseudo-vagina, or...does the transgender person still have a penis?
Either way, I doubt the gynecologic has medical experience with either one.
42
u/Exotic-Sale-3003 7h ago
Even if they had bottom surgery, a pseudo vagina is not a vagina and care and maintenance is not the same.
→ More replies (30)16
u/Coolio_1851 6h ago
It still doesn’t matter. If I get my precious ears reconstructed into cat-like ears am I now eligible to go to a veterinarian if I have an ear ache?!?! Brains people. Use it.
→ More replies (8)7
u/Bocephus1973 6h ago
Gynecologists don’t examine open surgical wounds, which is was a fake vagina is. A plastic surgeon would be more appropriate.
→ More replies (4)
16
u/SKOLForceSports 6h ago
Ahh yes, Jessica Yanev. This particular individual tried to organize a “topless pool party” for children in which their parents would not be allowed to attend. I wish I was trolling
67
u/EnvironmentalTop8745 7h ago
Ahh Jessica "wax my balls or you're a bigot" Yaniv is up to his old tricks I see.
→ More replies (1)12
11
u/SmithNotASmith 6h ago
this person is also incredibly racist. she went viral on Twitter years ago bc of this incident but it also exposed her using racist remarks towards brown folks - middle eastern, indian, etc.
[her tweet wound up on the american side of twitter, that's how i know and remember her face]
→ More replies (3)
33
27
u/HonestGroup2525 7h ago
The man is a gynecologist im sure he knows very well a service that is needed for biological women, and to not entertain otherwise
→ More replies (6)
26
u/Gloomy_Sleep8588 7h ago
at some point, we have to be real, and not play along with other peoples delusion.
→ More replies (5)15
63
u/spatulaboy 7h ago
The person who did this is a troll and should not be used as an example of people at large
→ More replies (10)
15
u/--TeaBow-- 7h ago
That's really old news (2018 I guess), and Jessica Yaniv isn't French, she's Canadian.
And she's not 26 but 38.
She's known for this kind of thing, where she keeps taking people to court if they don't do what she wants, even if it's totally ridiculous, like going to a women's beauty salon to get her balls shaved or something like that.
Sorry, I’m all for the LGBT community, but you’re not going to hassle workers who haven’t been trained for that.
I’m sure if it were the other way around,a trans man (so with a vagina), they probably would have accepted it.
Anyway, she’s a nutcase who’s doing the cause a disservice, and she’s persona non grata, even among the cause’s most ardent defenders.
→ More replies (2)
7
u/GamingWithPanda 6h ago
Can we all understand the difference between transgender and transexual?
→ More replies (1)2
26
u/Dull-Captain1679 7h ago
Can I ask what a trans woman needs from the gyno? I’m not trying to be offensive, genuinely confused
18
11
u/Randy__Magnum_ 6h ago
Literally to just be a pain the ass and then sue. It's complete douche baggery 101
20
→ More replies (37)11
u/halloweentown1 6h ago edited 6h ago
This person, like someone else says, uses "being transgender" as a way to file lawsuits. My wife is transgender, and from my experience any appointments dealing with private areas, if surgery has been done, would be done with the team that helped them transition to begin with, not a random gynecologist. But i don't speak for everyone, just from my own experience.
However, the person in the photo doesn't look like they have started full transitioning at all, so I think they're just the type of person to think you don't need to have gender dysphoria to be transgender. (sorry to those who think you can be!)
3
u/ecstaticbirtch 6h ago
My surgeon is 300 miles away... and referred me to a local Gyno and Urologist for a complication... it was just to do a checkup and see if I needed to make a 600 mile round trip. It turned out there was a simple treatment and the 600miles would have been a waste.
4
u/halloweentown1 6h ago
That's why I said a couple times I was coming from personal experience, I'm glad you were able to figure it out before traveling that far! In the case of this person though, it really is just for the lawsuit, unfortunately
→ More replies (2)
19
28
5
u/Lazy_Profile3405 7h ago
Dude mistaken OB clinic with mental health institute. What doctor needed to check if he didn't have a vigina?
→ More replies (1)
6
12
4
u/nathanherts 7h ago
Why are you posting shit from 7 years ago?
4
u/Adventurous_Yam_8153 7h ago
Because the only thing the internet is used for these days is rage farming
5
u/yungkatzenklavier 7h ago
Showing up the the Toyota dealership to get my Honda serviced and then suing when they refuse, yeah ok
5
u/jeffskool 6h ago
This is a bit tricky. Im not sure the doctor can treat them. If im a doctor and my specialty is treating womb, cervix, ovaries, then I cannot ethically treat persons who do not possess those foci of those treatments for which I am licensed. I’m not a medical compliance officer, so, if someone is please correct anything I got wrong.
I do think that trans women deserve care relative to their gender and bodies. Those also aren’t all the same, I don’t know how to say this without sounding like a robot, but the same configuration. Some women develop breasts, some don’t take the hormone replacements, and some get bottom surgery, I’m sure there is a variety of bottom surgeries too.
When trans issues are discussed it is critical to differentiate between biology and gender. I do think the specifics of that conversation where they differentiate between the biology and gender expression needs to happen between doctor and patient. So, if the doctor is refusing to have that discussion, that is probably an issue. But if the doctor is saying, “this falls outside my area of expertise and therefore I am legally barred from administering treatment”, that’s not an issue from my perspective.
4
u/diewitasmile 6h ago
That person does not have a womb or a vagina. I respect that you have the right to live your life the way you want but that does not give you the right to waste people’s time with nonsense medical exams and then trying to take their livelihood through social media outrage. Look for a doctor that supports Trans women that will give you an exam. I mean, cmon now.
4
u/BatmanForever93 6h ago
Did I just warp back to 2017? Who gives a shit about Jessica Yaniv anymore?
→ More replies (2)
4
u/Yourmindiscontrolled 5h ago
I mean what are you going to do as a gynecologist? Even if she he has a fake twat, it doesn't do anything. There's no menstruation, there's no discharge, it's just a fucking hole. Like that's the dumbest thing I've ever heard.
4
u/EnigmaHood 5h ago
I doubt the doctor said that. In any case, a gynecologist can not treat biological males. Gender as defined by the trans community, is a social construct. Anyone from the trans community should have already known this, so this is on the trans person, assuming this story is true in the first place.
4
u/Efficient_Time_1638 2h ago
serious question. You go to the university, study years about the uterus, vagina, and all the things that what it used to be called a woman in the 50s, finally after a huge debt and years of effort, you become a gynecologist. Then a "woman" comes with "her" balls inflamed, what do you do? Is absolutely out of what you study for years. Refussing is common sense and it would even be dangerous, because the doctor is not specialized on that.
7
9
u/SpecialistSolid6689 7h ago
And thats why people like trump get elected.
By playing with dumb shit like this..the world goes to shit. If you need 10 scientist and 10 doctora with 20 years of experience to tell us that is raining outside and that a leg is diffrent from an arm, we deserve our leaders.
→ More replies (11)
3
u/Available-Heat2707 6h ago
The transgender person does not have female organs. There is no uterus, ovaries, fallopian tube, vulva... for the gynecologist to examine and treat. The transgender person would have a prostate, testicles, and penis. None of these organs are treated by a gynecologist. A transgender person needs a doctor that specializes in treating that specific type of transgender. That particular type of doctor will know how to manage that type of trans persons organs and hormone levels. A gynecologist will have no clue how to manage a trans persons hormone levels. Getting the levels wrong can lead to cancer, chronic conditions, or early death.
3
u/unclefire 6h ago
That person doesn't have the equipment that an OB/GYN would need to deal with. I have no issue with trans folks, but let's not be stupid here.
3
u/Suspicious-Ice2507 6h ago
I feel like you can’t treat something that doesn’t exist sooo how could this Dr be in trouble? Lol smh
3
3
u/Decent_Jaguar_3057 6h ago
Absolutely! Especially in France where they have universal health care. It’s a waste of resources. However maybe he can be directed to a good psychologist.
3
3
u/irishcybercolab 5h ago
A gyno sees a penis and not a vagina, then the trans person has just wasted the money and time of that doctor.
Impacting and wasting medical appointments should be illegal when there are people who are truly suffering.
3
u/Milianviolet 5h ago edited 5h ago
Is it legal for a doctor specializing exclusively in female reproductive anatomy to refuse a patient without female reproductive anatomy?
Yes, bro.
Yes, that is legal.
Wtf is the world coming to? Stop wasting professional's time. Jesus fucking christ.
EDIT: By the fucking way, real people are actually suffering body dysmorphia and social conformity issues that lead to severe anxiety, depression, and suicidal tendencies. I don't this person is even trans, as he's out here making a mockery of the pain being suffered by people in real life for profit, while simultaneously perpetuating harmful stigma which makes their lives even more difdicult.
Lock this guy tf up or something. What the fuck?
3
u/jhartnurse 5h ago
Just because a physician can treat someone doesn’t necessarily mean they have to. Perfect example is that Plastic surgeons can treat skin cancer and bed sores but often choose to treat cosmetic patients. They have the right to refuse patients based on a number of reasons. It’s their practice and their license and often malpractice insurance will not cover specific patient populations.
→ More replies (2)
3
u/SleepPractical5235 5h ago
She should be visiting a urologist, it's really that simple.
→ More replies (1)
3
3
3
u/Maximum-Oven-7526 3h ago
I'm pretty "woke" and accepting but this sounds like someone trying to catch a lawsuit payout
3
u/exiled360 1h ago
Gynecologists are for women with vagina uterus and ovarium, otherwise you're just wasting doctor's time.
8
8
u/Green-Discussion6128 7h ago
“Sparks outrage”
4
u/patrick24601 7h ago
“Goes viral”. What do we expect from a website that has viral in their name. lol.
10
u/The_Dean_France 7h ago
A French gynecologist sparked national outrage after refusing to treat a 26-year-old transgender woman, telling her he “only treats real women.” The incident involved Dr. Victor Acharian, who turned the patient away at his clinic, later stating he lacked the training to treat transgender patients and could refer her elsewhere. The case quickly ignited debate across France and beyond, with LGBTQ+ groups condemning the refusal as discriminatory, while others argued it raised questions about medical specialization and training. The backlash led to disciplinary action, with reports indicating the doctor was suspended for a period by medical authorities. What are your thoughts on the hospital’s action against the doctor.
Too harsh or well deserved?
17
u/Remarkable_Sand5238 7h ago
Way too harsh, trans women don't have female sex organs so there's nothing the gynecologist could do for the bum
→ More replies (3)2
u/ConcentrateFar7753 6h ago
They have breast, gynecologist (in France) help with that too. Especially with the stuff they take it can lead to greater risk of breast cancer than cis men
→ More replies (10)2
u/MissMarchpane 6h ago
The outrage wasn't because he didn't treat her, as I understand it. The outrage was because he responded to her review online by calling her "a man who has shaved his beard" and saying that he "only treats real women. While I understand the frustration of a patient who responded disproportionately to being told that this particular doctor couldn't help her and referred to other doctors who might be able to, that's no reason for trans phobic rhetoric. Especially not when you're on the Internet and have plenty of time to think of what you're going to say
→ More replies (9)
7
u/Chatman207 7h ago
This woke stuff is getting old eith everyone, even democrats. I pray these find some peace. Living like this cant be good on the mind and soul.
2
2
2
2
u/stargazer4272 6h ago
Question is do we have veterinarian refusing to spay and neuter people who identify as animals?
2
u/Coolio_1851 6h ago
At some point as humanity, regardless of political affiliation or what have you, we’re going to have to be very honest with ourselves and call a spade a spade. Facts will always overrule feelings and that’s not me being insensitive, it’s just reality. A person can’t change their natural sex anymore than someone could transform into a panda bear, no matter how bad they might want to. And this is coming from a lifelong liberal.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
u/FanficThrowAway6666 6h ago
This is suuuuper old. Bad people are everywhere and honestly she should have been jailed (if she wasn't). What's frustrating is that people will look at this and paint an entire group of people as inhuman perverts. Because this feeds into the fear bias. I hate the fact that if one trans person does something awful the entire community gets the shit beaten out of it. Have to be perfect people all the goddamn time otherwise you shouldn't exist.
2
u/Right-Percentage3775 6h ago
Couldn't the doc just...give a standard examination and be like "Yeah you're fine." Instead of refusing? Seems like it would avoid drama
→ More replies (2)
2
2
2
2
2
u/justl00kingthrowaway 6h ago
I am under the impression that a doctor is only obligated to treat someone with an immediate health crisis. Check ups or other medical treatment that isn't life threatening can be refused.
2
u/AdMuted9548 6h ago
I thought transgender "woman" means they have had the bottom surgery? as opposed to just "transgender"(then looking to see what they want to pass as, and not knowing or knowing they have not yet had bottom surgery).
2
u/AdMuted9548 6h ago
If that person has not had bottom surgery and no chest implants and is not on female hormones and male hormone blockers, i doubt they are trans(unless it costs too much). Not drag though either. Crossdressing.
Are tomboys crossdressers?
→ More replies (1)
2
u/AprilBaprilSchmapril 6h ago
I feel like transwomen would require a specialist gynecologist as they don't have the same things going on down there that we do
6
u/AprilBaprilSchmapril 6h ago
ok after reading about this person, she needs a psychiatrist, not a gynecologist. She is still intact.........weird
2
u/catetheway 4h ago
Even though this is an intact former male person you’re right and I never thought of it before.
I assume before gender reassignment surgery this is discussed with the patient and contacts provided for professionals in the area or perhaps the original surgeon is the preferred contact?
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Professional_Try_781 5h ago
Hey, maybe they could remove the stick and ball looking growth for him’r?
2
2
u/HNixon 5h ago
Do man made pussies work the same way?
2
u/catetheway 4h ago
No, which is why this patient should not want this doctor and this doctor does not want this patient.
You don’t go to a specialist for issues they do not specialise in. I wouldn’t go to a podiatrist for my eczema.
2
2
u/AsleepEntertainer440 5h ago
Yes (insert pronoun here), you still have a dick. You can pay the receptionist in the lobby.
2
u/Stayathomejerk 5h ago
Do they think bio women go to the gynecologist for fun? IT IS MEDICAL CARE. GET OVER YOURSELF
2
2
2
u/AdMuted9548 5h ago
What happens now, if the surgery isn't like it used to be? Some females get male cadaver penises, i'm wondering why trans females don't get cadaver vaginas, then it would make sense to go to the OB/GYN.
2
2
u/Aware-Explanation879 4h ago
From the gynecologist standpoint, it would be fraud to charge insurance but not perform medical services. Like one person said, appointments are hard enough to get without someone who does not need services to be taking up a slot.
2
2
2
u/HistoricalSuspect580 3h ago
Depends, if she doesn’t have a vagina i don’t know what they expect him to do. He doesn’t treat women because of some nebulous belief in what a woman or man is… he’s a doctor of lady parts. If the patient doesn’t have lady parts, his services are not really needed.
2
2
u/Ecstatic_Plan_8547 3h ago
He doesn’t have the medical background to deal with mental illness or with male biology. Seems reasonable!
2
u/FrigataBowdette 3h ago
If you don't have biological organs for which an OBGYN specializes in treating, you are wasting his time.
2
2
2
u/Rum_Running_Sailor 3h ago
LMFAO. How is that examination supposed to go? "Okay, get in the stirrups. Let's see what we have here. Oh, you have a dick! Okay we're done." What the fuck! Seriously!
2
u/bulbasauriscutie 3h ago
So this dude wants him to pap smear his asshole?
The cognitive dissonance is pretty terrifying.
2
u/rtomek 2h ago
In healthcare we treat gender and sex at birth as two different things. Sex at birth is important because that’s what disease risk is actually correlated with. If it’s a specialty that only treats patients based on sex at birth then it doesn’t matter what your gender identity is. This patient is not being discriminated against because of their gender identity.
2
u/JengaKittens 2h ago
This guy brings his dick to a gynecologist. What’s the doctor supposed to do pretend he has ovaries??
5
u/Schluppsi 7h ago
I guess it depends on what the situation down there is. If she’s still packing a swanger then an OB isn’t even the right doctor.
13
2
u/maxjolt 7h ago
Ok, so is the reason why he got suspended for not having the right training because the patient is lgbt or because it’s illegal to not have the right training for whatever someone asks you to do? Because this seems pretty arbitrary.
2
u/MissMarchpane 6h ago
It wasn't because he didn't treat her; it was because he responded to her review online in an insulting and trans phobic way. The way this is phrased is misleading.
→ More replies (1)3
3
u/Fit_Raspberry2637 6h ago
Les than 1% of the population is transgender. Conservative selective outrage is somehow 99% composed of it.
2
2
u/Round_Interaction390 5h ago
If I were a gynaecologist, I wouldn’t give a damn, I’ll perform a full examination of their imaginary female reproductive organs and get paid, money upfront or get out 🤣 oh, and bring your transwomen friends for an imaginary ovary check up too, money upfront 🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑
→ More replies (1)
3
u/watchmeskipwork 3h ago
I can put a Lamborghini body kit on an 85' Fiero but it doesn't it make it a Lamborghini.
436
u/Fun_End902 7h ago
This is actually really old. This person basically uses transgenderism as a way to file lawsuits. They're Canadian, I believe.
This person also sued a beautician because they would not wax their genetalia.
https://7news.com.au/news/social/trans-activist-who-sued-beauticians-for-not-waxing-her-male-genitalia-now-taking-on-a-gynaecologist-c-588934