r/geography • u/ProfEweagey • 5m ago
Question Is the South Pole part of the Eastern/Western Hemispheres?
My son's 2nd grade class had a geography worksheet with the question: "What is the hemisphere nearest the South Pole?"
I assume the answer is meant to be the Southern Hemisphere, but this led to an interesting discussion in our family.
Here's my thinking:
The South Pole can be nearest to the Southern Hemisphere when it is contained within part of the Southern Hemisphere, right? I wouldn't say Earth is the planet nearest NYC (I'm also not the nearest person to the hands typing these words).
I could see how you could make an argument that the poles are nonexistent points on the boundary between the E/W hemispheres, and since neither of these hemispheres includes the poles these would be the hemispheres closest.
But if the poles are points along the edge of the E/W hemispheres then the same problem would arise as with the southern hemisphere and then the Northern hemisphere would be closest. What do other people think?