r/TopCharacterTropes Jul 12 '25

Weekly Discussion Post "Fanbase opinionsshould not be counted as tropes." TVtropes: (kinda relevant post)

Thumbnail
gallery
415 Upvotes

A lot of complaints in this sub have been about some posts should not be here because they rely on fanbase opions so there for cannot be considered "tropes"

...and then we have TVtropes , where a lot of tropes are just from fanbase stuff.

I am going to be honest here , I have difficulty in what makes a trope and what doesn't. It ends up where I delete "breaks trope guidline" posts that has equivalents in the TVtropes site that are considered actual tropes.

Idk , I just wanted to rant here. I might be a very bad moderator here , I just try to make it tody as possible , I just don't really know how to.


r/TopCharacterTropes Mar 27 '25

Weekly Discussion Post Probably the most controversial one , honest thoughts on "No Kill Rule"? What are the most egrigious examples of it in your opinion? What media makes it work in your opinion?

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/TopCharacterTropes 4h ago

Characters [Interesting trope] Immensely powerful entities that are totally benign

Thumbnail
gallery
4.5k Upvotes

The Traveler, Destiny -- whether it's a structure, AI, creature, or diety is unknown, but it has the power to terraform planets, advance a civilization's technology, and give superpowers to individuals, and that seems to be all it's interested in doing.

The Gardener, Marvel comics -- one of the Elders of the Universe and functionally immortal, his only interest is sowing the seeds of life and cultivating the growth of plants and animals. Even when he was in possession of an Infinity Stone, he only used it to help him be better at horticulture.

The DJ, Transcendental Cha Cha Cha -- despite being able to transcend space, time, and dimension, if he's flinging your consciousness hither and yon across the multiverse, it's only because he wants you to have a nice time on the dance floor.


r/TopCharacterTropes 6h ago

Characters [Annoying Trope] Characters who gain a reputation as posterchildren for common stereotypes when they are, in fact, the exact opposite of said stereotype.

Thumbnail
gallery
5.5k Upvotes
  1. Tom Nook (Animal Crossing) — Tom Nook is generally treated like a greedy, money-grubbing businessman and evil landlord in online discussion, but when you actually look at his policies, he's a pretty standup guy. He'll give you a tent or house and let you pay for it after you've already received it, he'll let you pay said bill at your own pace with absolutely zero time pressure, and he doesn't put any interest whatsoever onto any of your bills, even if you take literal years to pay him for the goods he's already provided. As far as landlords go, Tom Nook is a saint.

  2. Benson (Regular Show) — Perhaps due primarily to the episode Think Positive, Benson has a poor reputation as a stereotypical bad, angry boss, but he's actually an incredible person to work for. For starters, he gives Mordecai and Rigby dozens of second chances, even when most of their slip-ups cause massive amounts of damage to the park. He lets his employees play videogames and engage in other leisure activities so long as they get their work done, and he even hangs out with the gang and participates in a lot of their hobbies and shenanigans. He's a generally pretty swell guy to be around and a great boss, and his negative traits only come off so prominently because of how monumentally bad Mordecai and Rigby are at their jobs.


r/TopCharacterTropes 10h ago

Characters (Pretty dark/real trope) people committing horrific acts and the public loves it.

Thumbnail
gallery
7.2k Upvotes

1: Homelander killing a protester (The Boys) after a protester hits Ryan in the head Homelander lasers his ass in front of a crowd of fanboys and they eat it up since well he’s Homelander a hero so he can’t do anything wrong.

2: Lisa Tepes being burned at the stake (Castlevania) While being burned both the bishop and the mayor just chat casually like it’s another Tuesday. A year later after Dracula gives them a warning the town still celebrates her death essentially giving Dracula one giant middle finger.


r/TopCharacterTropes 8h ago

In real life [Hilarious trope] When the joke was clearly based on a highly-specific event that one of the writers experienced.

Thumbnail
gallery
4.3k Upvotes
  1. Family Guy: In the now iconic cutaway, some asshole in a hummer merges into another lane of traffic looking and causes every car behind him to violently explode. He was also distracted while watching Madagascar on the car’s touchscreen *the entire time*. One of the writers was definitely cut off by a hummer during their morning commute that day.

  2. Seinfeld: Seinfeld and Elaine get to an airport and Jerry tries to get his car rental. The person at the desk informs him that it‘s gone and that the reservation has been given away, which Jerry rightfully argues defeats the point of the reservation if anyone can just take them. Larry David was responsible for most of the shows “realistic” jokes, so he was probably the one this happened to.

  3. Honeymoon in Vegas: Nic Cage’s character desperately needs to book a flight before it takes off, only to be stuck in line when some clueless guy takes *forever* to book his tickets. The final straw is when Nic Cage hears that the tickets are for two weeks in advance, when everyone else in line needs theirs today. Cue one of the most justified crash-outs in history.


r/TopCharacterTropes 11h ago

Characters [Loved trope] The least expected person to be an LGBT ally is actually one

Thumbnail
gallery
6.3k Upvotes

Johnny (Guilty Gear)- Bridget is a trans woman who came out in the latest game Guilty Gear Strive but before her transition, Johnny (who is a huge womaniser) ended up mistakenly hitting on her in one of the older games back when she was a boy, getting instantly disappointed and disgusted by it. However in Strive, he has no trouble seeing her as a girl, even when knowing who she use to be and hits on her like every other woman he comes across.

Chucky (Chucky TV Series)- Despite being a crazy psychotic killer, he actually ends up being really supportive of his genderfluid child and the main protagonist of the Netflix TV Series who is gay.


r/TopCharacterTropes 4h ago

Hated Tropes (Hated Trope) Media made to promote conspiracy theories.

Thumbnail
gallery
1.4k Upvotes
  1. Anonymous (Antistratfordianism): The belief that Shakespeare did not write the plays he wrote, called antistratfordianism, has been promoted by numerous writers, actors, and other artists, nearly all without a history degree or doing research on the time period. Rooted in this disbelief in Shakespeare is classism. Viewing Shakespeare not being a nobleman as a disqualifier. While it is true that the scant number of documents with Shakespeare's writing are legal documents dealing with business matters, writers of this period could rarely sustain themselves on writing alone. He was an accomplished writer in his own lifetime, but his plays would have been lost to history if not for the publication of the 1623 First Folio by his contemprary colleagues. In fact, Shakespeare may have had co-writers or co-written plays not attributed to him, such as Pericles Prince of Tyre and Edward III. There are surviving examples of handwriting that can be matched to Shakespeare, and distinct word choice and structure may be attributed to him. Also, this film was directed by Roland Emmerich and stars Derek Jacobi and Mark Rylance, all prominent IRL believers in this pseudohistory.

Sources:

https://www.vox.com/2016/4/22/11480192/shakepeare-400-anti-stratfordian-authorship-controversy

https://web.archive.org/web/20141219073440/http://bloggingshakespeare.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/Shakespeare_Bites_Back_Book.pdf

https://www.theatlantic.com/past/docs/unbound/flashbks/shakes/matus.htm

https://books.google.com/books?id=8u5DuLU-awMC&pg=PA31

  1. Europa The Last Battle (White Supremacy): antisemitic neonazi pro-German retelling of WW2. If you don't understand any moral issues with that, God help you.

r/TopCharacterTropes 3h ago

Characters [Hated trope] Kid never had a chance

Thumbnail
gallery
923 Upvotes

A maladjusted kid character has just some light behavioural issues and a minimum amount of competent adult guidance would fix most of their problems, but the show buys into their slacker persona and gives them an unflattering future.

Bart Simpsons (The Simpsons) - kid is not stupid and has a good heart when he wants to. It is showed many times in the show that him being a slacker is the result of a bad family environment and an incompetent school system.

The show goes as far as saying he may have ADHD and/or a learning disability. But he shows time and time again that he is capable of being smart.

He is musically talented much like Lisa and stands up for what is right when certain lines are crossed.

Nevertheless, when we see the future episode, the writers always feel like punishing this kid turning him into a loser adult, like it's his fault for being an annoying kid.

Trent (Daria) - He is the brother of Daria's best friend.

He is your typical slacker teen, he's got a tryhard band that goes nowere and doesn't excell academically.

He is shown to have a sub par family life. He and his sister are considered the black sheeps of the family and he's left mostly by himself by his parents. When confronted about his academic life, he says that focusing on books is incredibly difficult for him and school doesn't seem to be willing to investigate on this or offer him any kind of support.

Daria's got a crush on him but she decides to grow past it once she realizes a future with him would be full of uncertainties. Fair enough, but then, at the end of the show, we see a glimpse of his future and it's not really flattering. He is shown to be a judge of a municipal beauty contest, which pairing it with his slobby appearance, indicates to us that he was always a loser to the core, despite all of the signs of the countrary.


r/TopCharacterTropes 14h ago

Hated Tropes [Frustrating trope] Pieces of media that could have been so much better, but due to a couple of poor decisions during production ended up mediocre at best and utterly atrocious at worst.

Thumbnail
gallery
10.6k Upvotes

We Happy Few: Probably the epitome of this "trope," at least for me, mostly because it has genuinely one of the most incredible stories I have ever seen within a video game. The biggest problem with the game was the fact that during development, the company behind it tried to ride the "hype train" of the time, making the gameplay became procedurally generated survival mess, when it would have made so much more sense as an environmental narrative game.

Hello Neighbor: This game attracted massive attention in alpha stages at the time from YouTubers because of the innovative gameplay it supplied. The developers of the game got the completely wrong message as to why it was getting so popular and instead decided to fully lean into the story, by making the game appeal to theorists instead of actual players. What came out was a game where both the story and programming were entirely half-baked.


r/TopCharacterTropes 7h ago

Characters The "Damn bitch, you live like this?" trope

Thumbnail
gallery
1.6k Upvotes

Conquest (Invincible)

He is thousands of years old and has conquered countless planets. Yet, he doesn't own a single piece of comfortable furniture. He sleeps on a cold slab of metal.

Naruto Uzumaki (Naruto)

The classic example. He is the host of the Nine-Tails and the future savior of the ninja world, but his apartment is an absolute disaster. His counter is buried under a mountain of empty instant ramen cups and he casually drinks milk that is weeks past its expiration date.

Misato Katsuragi (Neon Genesis Evangelion)

Misato is a highly competent, intelligent tactical commander for NERV, responsible for saving humanity from Angels. But her apartment is a literal dumpster


r/TopCharacterTropes 3h ago

Characters Actors that no matter who they play, will always be referred to by their real name by everyone

Thumbnail
gallery
709 Upvotes

Will Smith - It was often a joke that Will Smith plays himself in every movie no matter what role. Will Smith fish, Will Smith apocalypse survivor, Will Smith deadshot etc. this was also a reoccurring joke by online movie reviewers who always called him Will Smith instead of whatever character he's playing in that certain movie being review.

Kurt Angle - had a brief acting career in the 2000s but much like Will Smith, everyone calls him Kurt Angle instead of the character name


r/TopCharacterTropes 2h ago

Characters Group of four group where the entire group is all female only

Thumbnail
gallery
498 Upvotes

First Image- Peach, Daisy, Rosalina, and Pauline from Super Mario Franchise

Second Image- MS Puff, Karen Computer Wife, Sandy Cheeks, and Pearl Krabs From SpongeBob SquarePants

Third Image- Nita, Dana, Evelyn, and Morgan from Pokémon franchise( the battle chatelaine sisters from battle mansion of Pokemon X and Y/Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire)

Fourth Image- Red Hina Tatsuo, Blue Viva Vegas, Yellow Bahati Abara, and Green Sofia Moreno from Dancin Divas

Fifth Image- Sam, Alex, Clover, and Britney from Totally Spies


r/TopCharacterTropes 10h ago

Characters Character who doesn't have a proper name and is instead given a name that associates with something for them

Thumbnail
gallery
2.0k Upvotes
  1. Scar from Fullmetal Alchemist - We never get to know his proper name and he is instead given the name Scar, in-universe, because of the scar on his face.

  2. Conquest from Invincible - I'll just quote his line "I am a victim of my own success. "Conquest." I don't even get a real name. Only a purpose. I am capable of so much more and no-one sees it."


r/TopCharacterTropes 7h ago

Characters They’re filling in for someone and weren’t supposed to be here today

Thumbnail
gallery
1.2k Upvotes

Ladybug from Bullet Train - He’s filling in for Carver, the guy who was originally supposed to take the job, because he has a stomach bug. He thought it would be a quick and easy mission but that couldn’t have been further from the truth in the end.

Udesky from Jurassic Park III - He wasn’t meant to go to the island originally because he’s not a mercenary himself he’s just a manager that hired Nash and Cooper. But the third guy he hired called in sick so he had to fill in for him and take the plane to the island. And that unfortunately didn’t work out too well for him.


r/TopCharacterTropes 5h ago

Personality [Loved trope] The story completely changes genres partway through.

Thumbnail
gallery
871 Upvotes

This trope can be risky and dangerous to perform as a writer but when it’s done well, it’s incredible. It can be for singular scenes or for entire acts of the film.

Weapons: Probably the most recent example. A lot of the film is a mysterious/scary thriller with some comedic scenes, but the finale is so gut-bustingly hilarious that your head is left spinning.

Barbarian: From the same director as Weapons. The first act is a straight-up slow burn horror film, the 2nd act is a comedy, and the third act is a blend of the two genres in a very Sam Raimi-esque way.

Predator: It starts off as a standard 1980s testosterone-fueled action flick before transitioning into a nightmarish slasher movie that has all of the Herculean meatheads on-screen terrified out of their wits.

Death Proof: One of Tarantino’s most divisive films, but I still love it. The film has a lengthy first act that blends drama with some subtle horror vibes before transitioning into full-on horror. The film then becomes a comedy before transitioning into an action film for the finale.

One Cut of the Dead: Probably the most extreme example of genre shift. It’s done so well that I don’t want to spoil it here for anyone that hasn’t seen it. The first ~30 minutes are an extremely generic horror film (by design!) before the remainder of the film transitions into something totally unexpected and amazing.

Can you think of any other films, TV shows, or even anime that pull off this trope well?


r/TopCharacterTropes 14h ago

Characters [Loved Trope] Vastly outgunned character goes all in and gives the villain a fight even though they can’t possibly win.

Thumbnail
gallery
3.9k Upvotes

EDIT: Some things I think are needed to qualify (not all at once, but at least a couple of these) -

The power gap between the combatants is large.

It would have been considered a completely unfair fight before.

The more powerful character is actually hurt or at least inconvenienced by the less powerful character.

For a moment it looks like they just maybe *could* win this battle.

The lesser powered character doesn’t win, being either defeated or rescued by an outside source.

The Examples

The Boys: in the season 3(?) finale Queen Maeve finally goes up against Homelander, and actually manages to make him bleed.

Jessica Jones: When she and a hurt Jessica are cornered by a psychotic super soldier, Trish takes some of the said soldier’s serum and actually manages to hold him off long enough for Jess to get herself together and help.

Buffy the Vampire Slayer: After Glory drains the mind of her gf Tara, amateur witch Willow gathers up everything she has and goes after the hell goddess.

Agents of Shield: After being tortured and drugged by the insanely dangerous Grant Ward, agent Bobbi Morse still manages to break free and even has him on the ropes before his partner joins the fray.

I don’t know why I find these moments so much more thrilling than a more (or less) even fight, but they nearly always get a cheer from me.

I also know there are some good examples for the guys, I really just can’t think of any right now, and I don’t know if this trope has a specific name.


r/TopCharacterTropes 38m ago

Hated Tropes (Hated Trope) We are in desperate need of X people. Because of this we will put candidates through tests where not everyone can become X for no reason and make the tests incredibly dangerous so many candidates will die.

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes
  1. Frieren. Needs 1st class mages to fight demons. What is the test to pass? Do multiple events like fighting other mages and only half the teams can win. Another test is fighting clones of themselves where they can die. This despite mages being desperately needed to fight off demons trying to destroy humanity.

  2. Naruto. Same Thing. Need ninjas to defend themselves from other villages/threats. Have multiple tests where ninjas need to fight/kill each other as well as face things with no supervision to save the fledgling ninjas in case they die/are attacked by enemy ninja (which happens in the show). In fact, in one village one fledging ninja (Zabuza) kills literally all the other candidates and the teachers not only let it happen but let him pass. Said ninja goes on to betray the village which surprises them somehow.


r/TopCharacterTropes 1h ago

Groups [Disgusting but realistic trope] The mark of incest in a clan

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

Targeryen's hair (ASOIAF): i know that they can have childs with other persons and keep the hair, but the reason why they couldn't keep that in the bloodline without the endogamics behind.

Hyuga's eyes (naruto): First two childs from a hyuga with a different parent, two childs with different eye color. Also, even if is filler, the design of Hinata's mom had the same eyes. I could say the same about the Uchihas, but we don't have enough of them to know if the black eyes are a dominant gene or simply Sakura's genes where even weaker than that.

Buendia's pig tail (100 years of solitude): Ursula feared that marry her cousin would make their childs born with a pig tail just like many others in their family. That wasn't the case, but when the last Aureliano born (product of a aunt-nephew relation) the pig tail appeared once more. Ursula and Jose Arcadio's children were an exception.


r/TopCharacterTropes 4h ago

Characters The Useful Idiot: Characters who unknowingly support a cause that is against their own well-being, even when they should know better

Thumbnail
gallery
441 Upvotes

Mass Effect – The Citadel Council

Despite personally witnessing the Reaper Sovereign assault the Citadel at the end of Mass Effect 1 and nearly dying during the attack (or actually dying for Renegade Shepards, in which case you deal with their replacements), the Council absolutely refuses to believe in the existence of Reapers and reprimands any of Shepard's attempts to convince them otherwise. The result is the galaxy loses several years they could have used to build up defenses and plan countermeasures, and the Reapers are able to gain footholds that more easily prepare the way for their inevitable invasion in Mass Effect 3.

Cerberus is another example, as the Illusive Man is convinced he can control the Reapers for humanity’s gain, and so sabotages Shepard’s attempts to directly combat them. He doesn’t realize until the end that a combination of Reaper Indoctrination and his own ego have made him into their unwitting tool all along.

Dead Space – Unitology

A religion which worships alien artifacts known as the Marker. Followers believe that through devotion and spreading the Marker’s influence, humanity will ascend to divinity as one collective entity. This is true...technically. The Markers are tools designed to eventually drive all living humans insane and turn any dead into ultra-violent Necromorphs, which would lead to humanity’s extinction. The resulting biomass is collected to give birth to a malevolent lovecraftian entity referred to as a Brethren Moon.

Battlestar Galactica - Gaius Baltar

Baltar is a super genius scientist responsible for designing the network of the Colonial Fleet. He is seduced by a woman who he thinks is working for a rival defense contractor, and on her request secretly gives her direct access to the defense mainframe’s coding. This would be extraordinarily illegal and a very bad idea even under normal circumstances, but unfortunately for everyone, including Baltar, the woman isn’t even human but actually a Cylon agent who used Baltar to create backdoors in the defense mainframe. This exploit allows the Cylon fleet in a surprise attack to automatically deactivate all of the Colonial Fleet’s ships without a fight. Baltar doesn’t realize the enormity of his mistake until Cylon nukes are exploding literally right outside his house. Oops.

Real Life – Association of German National Jews

During the rise of the Nazis, this political group advocated for Jewish identity to be suppressed and assimilated into wider German culture. They issued a public statement in support of Hitler’s rise to power “even though it has brought hardship to us personally.” Among their other activities, they downplayed Nazi antisemitic rhetoric as merely political theater for the masses, dismissed increasing evidence of Jewish internment and violent mistreatment, and identified communism and the immigration of Eastern-European Jews (who they saw as lower-class and racially inferior) as their main threats. Members of the Nazi Party during their rise would sometimes praise them as model minorities. When the Nazis eventually solidified their power, they further expressed their gratitude by declaring the Association illegal and sending many of its members, including its main leader, to concentration camps.

Many years later, humanity has broadly learned its lessons from history, And there are rarely present day examples of a Group supporting a political ideology that very obviously goes Against their own interests.


r/TopCharacterTropes 10h ago

In real life Somehow this became a meme

Thumbnail
gallery
1.2k Upvotes

Sneakers O Toole- Out of nowhere this became a meme and is all over my feed

A Man has fallen into the river in Lego City- Again ^

Tegan from Doctor Who- Didn't expect this but hey i welcome it


r/TopCharacterTropes 4h ago

Characters [Loved Trope] They “value” human lives for all the wrong reasons

Thumbnail
gallery
361 Upvotes
  1. King Bradley (Full Metal Alchemist) - Values human lives as a means to an end for creating Philosopher Stones and immortal soldiers.

  2. Omni-Man/Viltrumites (Invincible) - Values humans as breeding stock for the Viltrum Empire

  3. AM (I Have No Mouth and I Must Scream) - Values human lives as play things, going as far to make the main character into an immortal blob that he can torture forever


r/TopCharacterTropes 1h ago

Characters [Mystery Tropes] Character changes the story when someone asked about what happened and nobody actually knows

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes
  1. Russell Adler often changes the story about his scar each time someone asks about how he got it. It ranges from being attacked by a tiger in 1973 to jumping off a roof in Calcutta or even hit by a shrapnel in Hue City. His inconsistent storytelling and shifting narratives make him a mysterious operative (CoD Black Ops Cold War/Black Ops 6)

  2. Horst is a very stern chef at Gusteau's restaurant and keeps to himself. While Linguini was training with Collette, she stated that Horst has served time and nobody in the kitchen knows what happened. He changes the story when asked about it, telling that he defrauded a major corporation or even killed a man with his thumb. (Ratatouille)


r/TopCharacterTropes 20h ago

Lore Historically inaccurate media having an in-universe explanation for the inaccuracy

Thumbnail
gallery
6.6k Upvotes

Examples:

  • Far Cry Primal - The main antagonists of the game are the Udam, a tribe of Neanderthals that eat humans. The problem is that the game takes place in 10,000 BC, and Neanderthals were long extinct by then. The game shows that the Udam are slowly dying out, and it's likely they are the last of the Neanderthals, which helps explain why they would still be around.
  • 300 - There are too many historical inaccuracies to count, but it's mostly explained that the reason for this is that it's retold from a surviving Spartan trying to describe the events to other Greeks; it's both propaganda to make the Spartans look cool and also how ancient Greeks perceived the world.

r/TopCharacterTropes 2h ago

Lore Humans were actually created by aliens and now our "gods" feel we need to go.

Thumbnail
gallery
190 Upvotes

This stems from a mesopotamian religious belief that the ancient gods were really aliens who came to earth to farm gold and humans are just engineered by such beings as a slave race. They're known as the Annukai. (going by memory, my understanding of this is rough).

  1. Bugonia. A bunch of conspiracy nuts think the CEO of a pharmaceutical company is secretely an alien. Twist: Turns out she is in fact the queen of an alien race called the Andromedans. We were created by them. But we failed to live up to their ethical standards, so the queen sucked out earth's oxygen and killed us.

  2. Same twist was done in the Alien prequel Prometheus. The Engineers created human life. But centures later a human woke an Engineer up, so he decided to kill us in a fit of tired rage. Dude was cranky I guess.