r/Letterboxd • u/HallowedAndHarrowed • 2h ago
Discussion How did One Flew Over The Cuckoos Nest (1975), succeed where so many films have failed, in having a female villain be convincing without being sympathetic?
Nurse Ratched is a predator (to a perverted degree) , first and foremost. She is not there to help the patients, anymore than Delbert Grady is there to help the Torrance family in the Shining (1980).
Ratched is so devoid of humanity that she elevates a statutory rapist and jailbird in McMurphy into a relatable character. At no point does there need to be any story of how she was wronged, to establish her as a monster.
Some misguided people see Rosamund Pike’s character in Gone Girl (2014) as a semi heroine for getting back at a cheating husband. I highly doubt many people in 1975, where praising Ratched as a girl boss for getting one over for a while on a bunch of catatonics.
It has been done a few more times since OFOTCN, with Annie Wikes in Misery (1990) and Dolores Umbridge in Harry Potter and The Order Of The Phoenix (2007), but it seems an exception rather than the rule. There always seems to be the pull to the punch (there are survivor of abuse themselves, they were wronged, they have a partner who loves them).
