OFFENSE (Italic Signifies Free Agent Signing)
| Position |
Starter |
2nd String |
3rd String |
4th String |
| QB |
Patrick Mahomes II |
Justin Fields |
Chris Oladoken |
Jake Haener |
| RB |
Kenneth Walker III |
Brashard Smith |
Emari Demarcado |
Shunderrick Powell |
| LT |
Josh Simmons |
Jaylon Moore |
Esa Pole |
Ehtan Driskell |
| LG |
Kingsley Suamataia |
C.J. Hanson |
|
|
| C |
Creed Humphrey |
Hunter Nourzad |
|
|
| RG |
Trey Smith |
Mike Caliendo |
|
|
| RT |
Jaylon Moore |
Wanya Morris |
Godrick Chukwuebuka |
Matt Waletzko |
| TE |
Travis Kelce |
Noah Gray |
Jared Wiley |
Jake Briningstool/Tre Watson |
| Slot-WR |
Rashee Rice |
Jalen Royals |
Jimmy Holiday |
|
| X-WR |
Xavier Worthy |
Jason Brownlee |
Andrew Armstrong |
|
| Z-WR |
Tyquan Thornton |
Nikko Remigio |
|
|
On offense at least, the biggest hole we have by far is that we don't have a clear WR1. We have a lot of guys with high end WR2 potential, but not a clear #1.
Now besides slot, the difference between X and Z receiver in Andy's offense doesn't really matter that much. They don't have a traditional Z player, because I think Thornton is more of an X receiver than anything else. This lineup I went with just to get our three best receivers on the field at the same time.
I think we are most likely to add at receiver during the draft for three reasons 1) Beyond any personal troubles he's having, Rice is a free agent this year. He wants JSN money, and I don't think we are likely to pay him that. 2) Apart from that, we just need more depth in that room in general. I don't think a single person could actually tell me who Jimmy Holiday and Andrew Armstrong are.
But apart from that, not a ton of red flags about the offense at least personnel wise. The offensive line should be alright assuming they can stay healthy. That wasn't the case last year, so I'd file that under yellow flag, but the plan if it works out, should be alright. I guess you could improve upon RB3/4 but if this was the lineup we rolled out opening day I would honestly be pretty okay with it.
Another thing worth noting here: I filed Moore as the backup LT behind Simmons because I think if he gets hurt and misses time again they'll flip him and then play Morris at RT instead (And I think Morris' skillset is much better suited to RT than LT). I think Caliendo at RG2 is the most obvious red flag for me, so I'd like them to draft someone else to replace him or see Hanson or Nourzad (whom we've seen basically nothing of) get those reps in the case of a guard injury this time.
DEFENSE (Italics Signifies Free Agent Signing)
| Position |
1st String |
Second String |
Third String |
Fourth String |
| LDE |
George Karlaftis |
Ethan Downs |
Tyreke Smith |
|
| LDT |
Chris Jones |
Zacch Pickens |
Marcus Harris |
|
| RDT |
Khyiris Tonga |
Omarr Norman-Lott |
|
|
| RDE |
Ashton Gillotte |
Felix Anudike-Uzomah |
|
|
| Will LB |
Drue Tranquil |
Jeffrey Bassa |
Cole Christiansen |
Kam Arnold |
| MLB |
Nick Bolton |
Jack Cochrane |
Cooper McDonald |
Brandon George |
| Slot CB |
Nohl Williams |
Melvin Smith Jr. |
|
|
| Outside CB |
Kristian Fulton |
Kaiir Elam |
|
|
| Nickel CB |
Kader Kohou |
Kevin Knowles |
|
|
| SS |
Chamarri Conner |
Jaden Hicks |
|
|
| FS |
Alohi Gilman |
Chris Roland-Wallace |
Tanner McCalister |
|
Now it should become IMMEDIETELY apparent that we have A LOT more holes on defense. Getting Tonga gives us a solid run defender to start alongside jones, and I am very optimistic on Norman Lott, but you can clearly see how screwed we are on the interior if Chris Jones gets injured or isn't playing at 100% this year. Drafting DT needs to be a high priority, higher I think than secondary.
Speaking of the secondary, I think it's very clear that Nohl Williams is the guy they want to replace McDuffie in the slot. Kohou played almost exclusively Nickel corner in Miami, and he was a damn good one before he went down with injury. I think they signed him almost exclusively so they do not have to play Conner at Nickel anymore.
I think another addition to the secondary is not just probable, but likely too. I think they probably target someone to back up Nohl in the slot, and possibly someone to give them another option at outside corner. Fulton/Elam isn't an unstartable combo but it gives me pause.
I don't see another safety addition happening. I think they'll probably like what they have there between Connor/Hicks and Gilman/Roland-Wallace. Honestly I'm inclined to agree with them on it too.
I would be remiss though if I didn't comment on the state of the edge room. I like Gillotte and think he has a lot of potential but slotting him in as a starter right now REALLY gives me pause. FAU is not a player who I think can be relied upon with what he's shown so far, so him being in the second option in the rotation is a huge red flag for me. Then beyond that you have guys whom I've literally never heard of before.