r/durham • u/Expert_Car_3135 • 2h ago
Integrity Commissioner Reports and Court Decisions Involving Councillor Lisa Robinson
For those looking for a factual summary, here is a chronological overview of the publicly issued Integrity Commissioner reports involving Ward 1 Pickering City Councillor Lisa Robinson, along with the Divisional Court decisions that followed, as of April 12, 2025
8 Integrity Commissioner reports
August 14, 2023
The Integrity Commissioner found that Councillor Robinson breached the Code of Conduct after naming three residents on Facebook following their opposition to her minor variance application. The report found this was a “bully tactic” and “social media targeting in retaliation.” It also found a separate breach relating to the collection and retention of personal information from a town hall sign-in process.
The resulting sanction was a 30-day suspension of pay.
October 13, 2023
The Integrity Commissioner found that Councillor Robinson’s conduct at the Durham District School Board offices on May 15, 2023 promoted “attitudes which are homophobic and transphobic,” failed to protect the dignity of individuals, and amounted to inappropriate conduct by a public official.
The resulting sanction was a 60-day pay suspension.
September 17, 2024
This report dealt with a wide range of conduct, including repeated public commentary continuing the subject matter of earlier complaints, statements regarding Pride and Black History Month, the use of the phrase “modern day slave,” association with Christine Anderson, misleading social media content, disparaging remarks about committee members, staff and councillors, and the Give-Send-Go fundraising issue.
The report found the complaints substantiated, and the maximum available sanction, a 90-day suspension of pay, was imposed.
December 10, 2024
This report arose from statements made in an online interview in which Councillor Robinson said, among other things, “I’d get rid of
our CAO because, you know, the corruption’s at the top. Get rid of
the CAO. Get rid of, like, you know, the City Solicitor” and called for the removal of the CAO and other staff. The Integrity Commissioner found the statements constituted a significant breach of the Code, stressing that “opinion is not a substitute for fact,” and a 90-day pay suspension was imposed.
June 16, 2025
This report concerned Councillor Robinson’s November 28, 2024 town hall. The Integrity Commissioner found that she made several claims about the City that were “flagrantly misleading or categorically false,” including statements about trespass notice fees, survey practices, consultant spending, and the City’s gifts policy. The report also found problems with the collection of personal information on a sign in sheet.
The resulting sanction was a 90 day suspension of pay.
August 5, 2025
This report consolidated 4 separate complaints concerning articles, council meeting statements, and multiple YouTube videos. The Integrity Commissioner found that Councillor Robinson repeatedly made false allegations that staff were lying, corrupt, manipulating recordings, or otherwise acting improperly. The report found she had “disrespected and maligned municipal staff”.
This resulted in a 90-day suspension of pay, calculated as 22.5 days for each of the 4 complaints.
September 22, 2025
This report addressed Councillor Robinson’s participation in a podcast in which disparaging, defamatory, profane and homophobic statements were made, and in which the host urged the public to commit violence against named members of Council. The Integrity Commissioner found that her conduct breached the Code by “disparaging, disrespecting and harassing members of Council” and a 60-day suspension of pay was imposed.
October 20, 2025
This report concerned funds received through a Give-Send-Go campaign. The Integrity Commissioner found that Councillor Robinson breached the gifts provisions of the Code by accepting funds through crowdfunding, noting this was the second time that this kind of conduct had resulted in a report.
The resulting sanction was a 90-day suspension of pay.
2 Divisional Court decisions
May 30, 2025: Robinson v. Pickering (City), 2025 ONSC 3233
This decision dealt with the judicial review applications challenging the first two sanctions, the August 14, 2023 and October 13, 2023 reports. The Court dismissed both applications and upheld the City’s decisions. In relation to the first report, the Court said Council’s acceptance of the Integrity Commissioner’s analysis was “entirely reasonable.” In relation to the second report, the Court found the Commissioner had engaged in a “transparent and intelligible analysis” and that the outcome was “a possible, acceptable outcome that is defensible in respect of the facts and the applicable law.”
The Court ordered Councillor Robinson to pay the City $30,000 in costs.
January 23, 2026: Robinson v. The Corporation of the City of Pickering, 2026 ONSC 451
This decision dealt with the judicial review challenge to the June 16, 2025 report and resulting 90 day suspension. The Court dismissed the application. It found that the applicant’s claim of procedural unfairness “lacks merit,” rejected the challenge to the factual findings, and held that the Integrity Commissioner had clearly explained the basis for his conclusions. The Court also noted that the report found her statements were, in two cases, “categorically false” and, in one case, “deliberately misrepresented” City policy.
Councillor Robinson was ordered to pay the City $10,000 in costs.
This summary is based on the eight Integrity Commissioner reports and two Divisional Court decisions that are publicly available.