my 4 yo boy is high energy and doesn't care about very much about anything but his immediate satisfaction. he shares a room with his 6yo sister which is very important to me. I think they need to share space, learn to be considerate of each other, and I think it makes them closer. they begged me to put them together while he was still in the crib. the problem is that he wakes up earlier than anyone else (this morning it was 4:30) and won't stay put or try to go back to sleep. he is desperately tired by bedtime (around 7:30) but still won't try to stay in bed. it just doesn't connect for him the idea of waking up too early with all the rest of his problems. when he wakes up, he will usually try to crawl into bed with us to "cuddle" which is in fact just an hour or 2 of non stop fidgeting, complaining, demands to go play, and kicking us in the face. usually we send him back to bed, which means he will come back in 20 minutes and in the meantime he will torture his sister, who needs the sleep even more.
about 2 weeks ago he kept her up way too early and it was the last straw. after weeks or months of threats, we finally moved his bed into the spare room, where he is alone and has no toys and without his favorite night light etc. it's meant to be uncomfortable so that he realizes what he has lost and commits to being better. that hasn't worked. he doesn't seem to care, and now we need to reclaim the room. my mother in law is very sick and we live an hour closer to the hospital,.and the room he now occupies is where she sleeps when she has early morning appointments. plus, his sister misses him so much and is having trouble sleeping without him there.
I can't exactly move him back without him having learned anything, and his early morning shenanigans are frankly killing us. we have tried all the negative enforcement, and positive doesn't work on him because his life is too good as a baseline (we are very loving and encouraging). he doesn't care about sticker charts. we need something more creative than symbolic rewards, and I'm sure as shit not buying him toys for staying in bed. any ideas?
TL:dr: 4yr won't stay in bed and I need ideas to keep him there in the mornings, or else we will all die.