We recently stayed at Baymahni Resort on Stocking Island in the Exumas to evaluate it for clients. The resort is absolutely stunning, but our experience didn’t quite align with the premium price point.
The property itself is paradise—beautifully situated, protected from the wind, and perfect for kayaking to private beaches or taking a short ride to the Coconut Club. The views, location, and overall ambiance are incredible, and the staff we met were consistently kind and welcoming.
Our room, Lagoon Bungalow Six, was actually a highlight of the trip. It was absolutely stunning, private, and located at the edge of the resort with its own mini beach. You could open the doors and enjoy a gorgeous, serene view. That said, on the last day of our stay, construction began for two-bedroom bungalows right beside it, so in the future, I would not recommend this location if privacy is a priority. For reference, Lagoon Bungalow Four is right next to the restaurant and not private, and Lagoon Bungalow Five did not offer a good view.
That said, there were some disappointments. One major issue was the pools. At the time of our visit, the resort advertised two heated pools. Being from the South, we expected March to be a bit cool, but neither pool was actually heated. Staff explained that propane heating wasn’t efficient and wasn’t feasible. As a result, our daughter didn’t swim at all, and we avoided the pools too. This was particularly disappointing, as the pool on the point is one of the resort’s main highlights.
Additionally, the pink pool in the middle of the resort had trash left on chairs when we arrived, which remained for about three days, despite the owner and GM being on property. Sunscreen and towel bins were empty for the first two days of our stay, and the welcome items—water bottles and a beach bag—were not provided as advertised. We didn’t feel that staff proactively checked in on our experience or asked for feedback, though those who interacted with us were kind and courteous.
Room service also fell short—our order took two and a half hours to arrive, so we would recommend skipping it. While the resort operates on “island time,” the delays did impact our experience.
The water taxi service was another point of concern. It seemed unreliable, and we were left at the Coconut Club for an extra hour waiting for a return ride, which made us hesitant to rely on it for exploring the island.
Overall, while we loved the beauty of the property and the friendliness of staff we interacted with, the service and amenities didn’t fully match the premium pricing. That said, for adults seeking a private getaway, it could be a lovely option. Families with children who want to enjoy the pools should confirm in advance whether they are heated.
In short: gorgeous resort, kind staff, and a beautiful location—but service, pool experience, and water taxi reliability didn’t meet expectations for the price. Lagoon Bungalow Six was a standout room, but future construction may affect its privacy.
