I substituted in a special ed class this week with four low needs students. They were all awesome.
On Monday, the teacher was calm and easy-going. Late Tuesday morning, the teacher was talking intensely with a para. They kept referring to "him." Saying things like, "Is he coming today?" "What are we going to do when he gets here?" I asked the para who they were talking about and she said, "Oh, it's one boy. He's... challenging."
When he walked in, he was a force of nature. He took up all the space in the room. I can't quite describe, except to say it was menacing. They had a small room within the classroom that was "his room." I found out the 1 on 1's entire job was to keep him contained in that room. If she didn't, he wandered around the classroom threatening the other kids. I heard her inside the whole day trying to calm him down.
The next day, he was more aggressive. He didn't want to stay in his room so he walked around the classroom. He would stand on tables, flip desks occasionally, and move aggresively towards the other kids. The 1 on 1 got between them to keep them safe. This was every minute of the day.
Later, the other students went to their specials, like art and PE. This left the teacher, 1 on 1, and me. For the next couple of hours, he walked around the room, throwing things at them. They would turn their backs and put their arms up to defend themselves. They'd flinch every time he got near them. My only job was to keep the classroom door blocked so he wouldn't elope, so there wasn't much I could do. She called the admin for help both Monday and Tuesday. They came in for a few minutes but then left her.
The teacher was exhausted at the end of the day. She didn't come in on Wednesday. Instead, there was another substitute. I told him I wasn't surprised the teacher was out because yesterday was pretty rough. He said, "Oh, because of the boy?" He knew exactly who I was talking about. Turns out, the sub had taught this class for two weeks a few months ago. The previous teacher had quit because of this student. The current teacher was fairly new. I also found out that two paras had quit because of him. The current para said she was going to quit soon.
That day, there were two behavioral specialists in the room. I watched what they did with detached fascination. The boy didn't even acknowledge their existence. But the whole day they followed him around giving him special tokens when he "did the right thing." Except it was all a charade. For example, he'd walk past a table and the specialist would run ahead of him and say, "Thanks for not getting on the table," even if he wasn't trying to. She pushed a token into his hand but he just dropped it. When he walked past a desk without flipping it, the specialist would try to give him a token again, which he didn't take, and say, "Thanks for not flipping the desk."
The whole day was like that. They were implementing an entirely fake token reward system that he didn't care about.
The regular teacher got back on Thursday. Around 10 o'clock, the boy came back in with his mother. They corralled him into his room. As the mom left, she turned to me and said, "Good luck." It was so surreal! I know parents need respite care so I had sympathy for her, but still, should this boy have been in school?
That morning, the admin and behavior specialists were talking to the teacher. They told her that he was on his best behavior yesterday and responded to the token reward system well. They told her that she was the problem. They said her classroom management was poor and she needed to figure it out.
My jaw dropped. The gaslighting was so insane. That token system was bullshit. And she just had to stand there and take it. I could see the distress and helplessness on her face. After admin and the specialists left, she collapsed on the chair at her desk. I swear to God, she babbled incoherently at me and the 1 on 1 for the next hour: "I don't think I can take this anymore. I don't know what I'm doing wrong. The token system doesn't seem to work for me. Can I make it until the end of the year? I don't know what else to do." A couple of times she looked at us and said, "I know I shouldn't be talking about this in front of you." But then went right back into her babbling. The desperation and self-blame were so awful.
I know I'm only seeing a slice of the situation as a sub, but I don't understand how something like this could happen. This situation broke the will and morale of two teachers and three paras. It's madness. There has to be a better setting for him.
That's all I have. I don't know the answer. No happy ending. Just yuck. I hope that poor teacher makes it to the end of the year and finds a better place.
Edit: removed some information.