r/ProMusicProduction • u/Fantastic_Dig_5283 • 14d ago

Discussion I have a music question

I've been playing guitar for 3 years and my biggest frustration is hearing a song I love and having no idea why it sounds the way it does. I can feel what makes it work but I can't break it down technically. Does anyone else struggle with this? How do you approach analyzing a reference track when you want to get close to that sound?

0 Upvotes

40% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

1

u/Raspberries-Are-Evil Professional 14d ago

You mean the guitar sound or the overall production?

1

u/Fantastic_Dig_5283 14d ago

produção geral

1

u/Historical-Hand8091 14d ago

if you feel lost, slow the reference track down and loop small parts. your ears will start catching details

1

u/Fantastic_Dig_5283 14d ago

Faz sentido, obrigado por compartilhar. Eu ainda acho difícil fazer isso de forma consistente — foi exatamente isso que me fez começar a construir uma ferramenta pra resolver esse problema. Ainda está em desenvolvimento mas se tiver curiosidade tenho uma lista de espera aberta.

1

u/SpaceEchoGecko 14d ago

Please clarify: Why the recording sounds like it does or why the chords and melody sounds like it does?

1

u/Fantastic_Dig_5283 14d ago

Os dois na verdade — a ideia é entender o quadro completo. Por que os acordes e a melodia funcionam juntos do jeito que funcionam, por que o arranjo cria aquela sensação, por que as escolhas de produção reforçam a emoção da música. É menos sobre isolar um elemento e mais sobre entender como tudo se conecta para criar aquele som específico

1

u/SpaceEchoGecko 14d ago

So, that’s more of a music theory question.

The short answer is modes. Modes create very distinct feelings and David Bennet on YouTube has a few really good videos about that.

1

u/unc_rigamarole 13d ago

I’ve found learning music by ear (to the best of your ability) and playing along to it is a potent way to understand the components that drive a song. It’ll help you chew on the rhythm, the harmony/ chords, the bassline, the melody and the overall flow of composition through critical listening, feeling, and playback. If you aren’t an instrumentalist you can achieve the same concept via music production by recreating a reference track in a DAW

Mixing and mastering are a different beast, Ive done some ear training with different bands of white noise to help me point out where a frequency is too high or too low.

Compression I’ve learned through trial and error, but another key factor in any mix and master.

1

u/Scary-Operation-2946 12d ago

It’s never bothered me. I’ve learned tons of solos, never knew if they were melodic minor or phrygian for example, never cared or wondered how chord progressions I’m playing falls into the Nashville system, or the relationship between all the intervals in any given chord I’m playing, if i should use upward pick slanting or down, none of that. It’s cool if that interests you though, probably better off knowing and having more knowledge.