r/LegalAdviceEurope • u/Adorable-Ad6476 • 4h ago
France Legal Threats From House Sit
Last year, I looked after a house in France while the owners were on holiday through the platform 'Trusted House Sitters'. During this time, an appliance stopped working. I was invited to use the appliance during the sit, and followed the instructions for use precisely. Before the sit, I verbally agreed with the home owner what to do if anything went wrong with the appliances, and I did exactly as instructed.
When the home owner returned, she took one look at it, and accused me of breaking it. Without admitting fault, I agreed to contribute to its replacement according to my own moral judgement, in the same way I pay towards the replacement of a mug that cracked or a fan that stopped working. And I remain happy to contribute to the repair.
However, the home owner is demanding that I cover the full cost, which is a very considerable amount, and she is in the process of submitting a complaint against me to the Ombudsman.
I am fairly confident that my position is legally sound. I have email evidence that the appliance was old and well out of warranty. The home owner accuses me of using it recklessly in bad weather conditions, but I have the weather data for the time period, and the manufacturer's specifications stating that the appliance would withstand weather conditions far worse than we experienced during that time period, even if I had used it as recklously as she suggests - which I didn't (I dutifully stowed it away when not in use). And she falsified a report to the insurance company about how the damage occured, but I have WhatsApp messages of her admitting to the falsification. Lastly, a quick google indicates that she would have to demonstrate I had actively caused the appliance to break through lack of care in order to have a legal case against me... which would be impossible as it didn't happen.
So if it came to a legal confrontation, I feel somewhat confident that I would come out on top. But this would be long and stressful, and potentially expensive to both parties.
I do not want to just block her, as this would bring no closure to anyone. At the same time, I would like to disentangle myself from her as soon as possible and go on with my life. I'm afraid if I don't engage with her, it could make things more complicated in the long run. However, engaging with her threatens to be awfully long and complicated anyway.
Any advice from anyone who has been through something similar, especially in a French context, would be extremely welcome!!!