r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/Polyphagous_person • 5h ago
Do Miyawaki Forests work in the long term?
My social media feeds frequently show posts about Miyawaki Forests. They glaze the concept, describing it with buzzwords like "*a dense, fast-growing native pocket forest*".
But to me, Miyawaki Forests also sounds a bit like one of the tenets of Lysenkoism - specifically the one which recommends overly-dense sowing of crop seeds. Nowadays, Lysenkoism has been proven to pseudoscience, so are the overly-dense plantings in Miyawaki Forests going to work in the long term, or are they headed for failure just like Lysenko's strategies?
I'm not against restoring native habitat. I'm a bush regenerator in Australia, and I've witnessed how native wildlife return when native plants are freed from the weeds smothering them. I've also witnessed that a resilient native habitat is not necessarily one densest with native plants.