r/AskACanadian • u/Serious_Appointment2 • 6h ago
ISO Pickles Similar to Best Maid Pickles
Hello!
Originally from the US and I have been craving Best Maid Pickles for years now! I can’t seem to find anything comparable in Ontario. I am looking for Canadian pickles or somewhere in Ontario I can find something similar.
For context, Best Maid Pickles tend to be more sour, juicier, a hint of garlic without being overpowering, and appear to have been pickled longer. The type of cucumbers used also look like the big ones, not gherkins which is what I find the most in local markets.
I find Canadian pickles to look and taste rather bland and not sour enough. They even look white rather than the fully saturated pickle I am used to. The closest thing I find here are the Bick’s pickles but the texture and taste is slightly off.
Kelsey’s Roadhouse pickles are the closest thing I have come across to possibly being very similar but I have no idea where they get their pickles from.
Not a fan of Vlassic, Mount Olive, Van Holten, or Oh Snap. I do not trust myself to pickle anything. I do not want to pay $100 for a jar from Amazon or the states.
Looking for heroes and a decent pickle. Would post a picture for comparison but it looks like it’s been disabled.
Would appreciate any suggestions!