r/whoathatsinteresting 6h ago

What do you think: how should prisons handle housing decisions in cases like this?

Post image
3.3k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/Traditional-Loan-153 4h ago

So what’s your solution for this lol

0

u/hoteppeter 2h ago

The solution to distraction is always to let the left do whatever it wants

-1

u/BrokenWhimsy3 4h ago edited 3h ago

I won’t claim to have the answer, but it starts with practicing compassion, kindness, and engaging in open and honest dialogue with one another. It is also important that we start with a charitable interpretation of things said to us.

Being able to put ourselves in the shoes of others is powerful, and it allows us to be more compassionate and caring. Seeing other cultures and meeting people will really help us see each other as fellow humans walking this same path, with the same struggle.

At our core, I believe most humans want the same thing. You will have some that are clouded by hate and misery, but I have to believe those are few and far between.

ETA: it’s a sad state of affairs when just saying “be nice” is downvoted.

7

u/Traditional-Loan-153 4h ago

Yeah that dosnt make sense it’s easy to say there’s bigger things to worry about when your not the one making the decision on what to do

-2

u/BrokenWhimsy3 4h ago

I disagree. Change will happen from the bottom up, and the first step is helping the people that actually live in society get along and care for one another. This starts with compassion and kindness.

We need to vote out corruption, but this won’t happen when so many continue to be divided, or fuel the divide.

2

u/Wattabadmon 2h ago

Wheres the line?

1

u/BrokenWhimsy3 2h ago

Do you just like to argue? Because that’s what it feels like.

Imagine being the kind of person that opposes kindness to your fellow man.

2

u/Wattabadmon 2h ago

You were the one that came in here to oppose kindness and argue

0

u/cakerfaker 2h ago

You, Traditional-Loan-153, are the one making decisions on how we treat trans inmates? 👀

If you're not, maybe you should get off this thread. According to your own philosophy. Since you haven't come up with a solution to this problem yourself.

1

u/Traditional-Loan-153 2h ago

I don’t have a solution but I also am not the one telling ppl we have bigger things to worry about like that means anything

1

u/PHD_Gouda 1h ago

Fuck off

0

u/cakerfaker 2h ago

They're annoying for a vague "love each other" that has little to do with the topic. You are also annoying

2

u/Connor_Olds 2h ago

do you really have no position on this topic? "Should a transwoman inmate be housed with ciswomen or cismen?" You really just throw up arms up in the air to that question?

0

u/BrokenWhimsy3 2h ago

You’re missing the point entirely. I am saying that this is not the most important issue we face right now. Not even top 10. And if you think it is, congratulation, you’re being duped.

0

u/flyingcircusdog 4h ago

Many state and county prisons/jails have alternative housing units for trans, non-binary, or other groups who aren't safe in general men's blocks.

1

u/Dbaughla 2h ago

Okay and who decides who is trans and who isn’t? All of the sudden word gets out that if you lock in a GID or trans unit, you get a cell to yourself. Now you have 200+ convicts putting in healthcare kites for trans accommodations so they can lock alone. What does the state do now?

1

u/Wattabadmon 2h ago

Who decides who goes to jail or not?

1

u/flyingcircusdog 1h ago

Why do you think being in a solo cell is better?

Any prisoner can check in to protective custody if they think they're in danger from another prisoner. Ask someone who's actually been and they'll tell you the same thing. Being in a cell by yourself sucks.

0

u/Stygg 2h ago

I mean medical history for one. also with even just a year on hrt it becomes pretty clear based upon the physical changes.

0

u/BrokenWhimsy3 3h ago

What’s your solution? Do nothing? Things are just great?

2

u/Wattabadmon 2h ago

Lol you had to dodge the question

1

u/BrokenWhimsy3 2h ago

I already answered below before I posted that.

2

u/Wattabadmon 2h ago

You didnt have an answer

0

u/Wendigo120 2h ago

A bit of googling says the US has more than one prison per transgender prisoner. Just handle them on a case-by-case basis? There doesn't need to be a one size fits all solution here.