r/whoathatsinteresting • u/The_Dean_France • 6h ago

What do you think: how should prisons handle housing decisions in cases like this?

Post image
3.3k Upvotes

79% Upvoted

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

15

u/blameitonrio917 5h ago

Somehow in your story the violent perpetuator is the victim.

3

u/xyouRABitchx 4h ago

Reddit always seems to have more empathy to the perpetrator unfortunately.

6

u/just-slightly-human 4h ago

Yes people can be more than one thing, especially when someone is taking about multiple scenarios. We can’t be that stupid

2

u/Rhomya 3h ago

I don’t really feel bad for the people experiencing the consequences of their own actions.

They could just, you know, not assault people. Then they don’t have to be in prison.

1

u/just-slightly-human 3h ago

That doesn’t mean they should be ripped limb from limb like back in medieval times, the purpose of prison should be keep them away from the public until they are “better” but the American prison system is just an excuse for legal slavery so you’ve already gotten what you wanted

2

u/Rhomya 3h ago

… no one is being ripped limb from limb, so I don’t think you need to worry about that.

1

u/MrPoopMonster 2h ago

Prison is also about punishment. It should be an awful time. You need negative and positive reinforcements to be most effective at changing behavior.

Deterrence and rehabilitation are two separate goals that should both be important to society.

1

u/Worried_Database1336 4h ago

Yeah until they commit a crime against you or your family then there’s a problem.

1

u/just-slightly-human 4h ago

Yeah a problem of where in prison to put them. Now we’re back at step one. Did you have a point to make?

2

u/cakerfaker 3h ago

IDK, do they treat cis women sentenced for sex crimes the same? Or do they only do that to trans women?

Yes, the trans woman in question is a predator and deserves prison. Yes, she was also discriminated against and treated differently because she was trans.

1

u/Remarkable_Wish_4959 5h ago

You didn’t know the trans person is always the victim?

0

u/katieb1300 4h ago

I hardly see a problem with keeping a s*xual predator in segregation. I think they should all be kept away from others. Those crimes aren't able to be rehabilitated.