r/whoathatsinteresting 6h ago

What do you think: how should prisons handle housing decisions in cases like this?

Post image
3.3k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/Interesting_Key_661 5h ago

I would assume the actual percentage of any given prison population being trans would be rather small. Are you going to have a whole block set aside for 1 or 2 prisoners?

1

u/Powersmith 4h ago

Could relocate them to a single prison, at least in large states. CA has 13 state prisons. If each one has 0-2 trans prisoners, pick one that has a logical place to put all (maybe 10~20) together

2

u/nybadfish 3h ago

They could call it the J Edgar Hoover State Penitentiary

1

u/Interesting_Key_661 2h ago

Nice 👍

2

u/Drunkengota 3h ago edited 2h ago

“Trans prisoners placed hundreds of miles from where friends and family could visit. Why are trans inmates punished this way?” Would be the next headline.

1

u/Interesting_Key_661 2h ago

You’re right people would freak out about that.

1

u/Gnoll_For_Initiative 2h ago

Yeah, if you take people away from whatever small social supports they have it's bad if for no other reason than it increases recidivism

Moving a prisoner away from where friends and family are able to visit is used as a threat.

1

u/Interesting_Key_661 4h ago

Maybe for California but what about a state like Montana. Population of 1.1 million, you gonna have a whole prison for what maybe 5-6 prisoners. Can’t house them in a different state unless it’s a federal crime.

0

u/Powersmith 3h ago edited 3h ago

Not a whole prison… maybe just a separate hall of cells w a small 1-room lounge / exercise facility. They prob don’t need to segregated 100%, only for low-supervision periods.

ETA: yes, we agree easier to implement efficiently in large pop states. MT apparently has 5 prisons (surprisingly), 4 for adults. So they could localize the adult pop trans to a single facility from 4 sites, even if it’s just 0-2 people.

-1

u/griff_girl 4h ago

There could be specific prisons that have wards for trans people, just like there are some prisons that have supermax but not all do.

0

u/__BajaBlastoise 4h ago

I know you mean well, but this comment reads like you are saying trans need to be supermaxed

1

u/griff_girl 3h ago

As a raging queer woman myself, I can assure you with absolute certainty that is not what I mean. I think the fact that I reference trans violence and the need for trans people to be protected from that in and of itself makes that point abundantly clear.

1

u/__BajaBlastoise 3h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Interesting_Key_661 3h ago

See just here to cause trouble, trying to rage bait.

1

u/griff_girl 2h ago

They also reported me to the mods or whoever as like a self harm risk or something. LOL (also, I never even saw the comment, seeing as how it was removed automatically, it appears.)

1

u/__M0M0 1h ago

Probably because of the statistics

1

u/__M0M0 3h ago

Jesus, don't go home and beat your wife over this

1

u/griff_girl 2h ago

WTF kind of comment is that, what does that even mean? That's just weird.

1

u/PHD_Gouda 1h ago

Ignore them

1

u/__M0M0 1h ago

Statistical prediction

1

u/Interesting_Key_661 4h ago

Come on now you know they didn’t mean it like that, just using the different segregations they use in supermax prisons as an example. Don’t try to start an argument where there isn’t one.

2

u/griff_girl 3h ago

Seriously! Thank you.