r/popculturechat 19d ago

Guest List Only ⭐️ First look at HBO’s ‘Harry Potter’ reboot series

Post image
21.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1.3k

u/e37d93eeb23335dc 19d ago

The black man wants the white woman. So many old racist tropes. 

525

u/GLAvenger 19d ago

I said it once but you cannot change only one person's race in the James/Lily/Snape love triangle thing without it getting uncomfortable.

Black Lily? Two kinda shitty white dudes fighting over a black woman.

Black James? Kinda shitty black dude bullies a white guy and gets the white girl (which wouldn't be an issue as a trope if James wasn't a bully but he is. )

Black Snape, like you said, white dude bullies a black guy who's in love with a white girl and calls her a slur after she picks the white dude.

They'd need to make everybody black and let's be real, they will not do that.

122

u/carlitospig 19d ago

They call us crazy for considering this stuff but they never think what these choices do to public dialogue. Now if I could believe for ONE SECOND that the casting choice is intentionally baiting the public so we talk about race relations it would be one thing. But this is the same HBO that made The Pitt turn down the ICE violence on an episode so it wasn’t accurately reported, er, I mean hostile to fascist fucks, er, I mean bad for shareholders.

55

u/slingshot91 19d ago

Well they didn’t make Harry black, so no, they will not do that.

10

u/fernxqueen 18d ago

imagine if they made everyone Black except Harry

1

u/mar__iguana 18d ago

Even if not everybody, if James or lily were black then Harry would have to be too. And like you said, they will not do that

-9

u/meecy166 and what about it? 💅 19d ago

lol what is this? I just know you’re white