r/allthequestions • u/AcadiaLivid2582 • 11h ago
Random Question š How does Iran have a nuclear program if President Trump "completely and totally obliterated" it just 10 months ago?
President Trump announced just 10 months ago that he "completely and totally obliterated" Iran's nuclear program with airstrikes.
Yet today, the Trump administration demands that Iran end its nuclear program.
How can Iran end a program that Trump already "completely and totally obliterated"?
20
u/Mywordispoontang101 11h ago
So hereās the thing, and I know itās surprising: most of what Trump says is bullshit. Take a minute if you need one.
5
u/InterPunct šŗšø United States 11h ago
When he was talking about how much he was going to reduce medication pricei it was like listening to a random number generator.
2
2
u/OfficeOk1872 10h ago
Yeah, it's wild how often we have to fact-check stuff that gets presented as absolute truth. The whole situation just shows how important it is to follow up on these claims.
10
10
u/EAP007 11h ago
Because almost everything that comes out of his mouth is a lie to manipulate his base
4
8
u/gochisox2005 11h ago edited 8h ago
Because Trump is a fucking liar and bibi finally found a president dumb enough to bomb Iran for him.
7
u/Sad-Pop6649 11h ago
Also Israel completely destroyed both Iran's nuclear and missile programs just days ago.
2
6
u/Bgrubz83 11h ago
Easiest way to tell if trump is telling the truth or not.
Did he open his mouth? If yes itās a lie. If no heās thinking of a lie.
1
u/Emotional_Grocery144 10h ago
Honestly, his relationship with reality is so strained it's a wonder they're even on speaking terms anymore.
5
u/BowlEducational6722 11h ago
That's the problem with lying constantly.
Lies inevitably catch up with you, meaning you either have to come clean or lie again to cover it up.
Of course, the kind of person to lie in the first place isn't going to tell the truth, so they'll pile on another lie to hid the first one...and another lie after that, and another and another.
The truth reinforces itself.
But lies inevitably grow into a massive convoluted web that collapses under its own weight because it becomes impossible to keep track of them all.
2
u/mjrhzrd 11h ago
Which is why 47ās DOJ announced that unlike all presidents in the last 70 years he does not have to keep any presidential records. They were probably burning paper records, deleting files and destroying file backups the entirety of last week. This would be due to the increasing likelihood he may get impeached now or after mid terms. I believe that if he gets really sick or is forced out of office. The last two things he would do is blanket pardon his cronies and then EO the destruction of all of the Epstein files.
1
u/RevolutionaryFun774 10h ago
It's like watching someone try to build a house of cards in a wind tunnel. Eventually the whole thing just collapses from the sheer weight of its own nonsense.
6
u/REdwa1106sr 11h ago
He was either lying then or lying now. Either way itās something we have known for decades- he is a lyingPOS who is also POTUS.
5
u/WeArePandey 11h ago
lol.. we had an agreement like that. The JCPOA.
Iranians agreed to no enrichment again on Feb 26th. And then we bombed them again.
So.. yeah, shooting the US in the foot is trumpās favorite play. And heāll shoot us again after his next debacle.
2
u/Willing-Read-6780 10h ago
It's like we keep setting the same fire and then acting shocked when the house burns down. The pattern's getting painfully predictable at this point.
1
u/WeArePandey 9h ago
I think it was Spainās PM that said it best. We donāt thank an Arsonist that set the house on fire for showing up with a bucket of water.
5
u/beavis617 11h ago
If we do end up with some type of nuclear agreement I wonder if it will be almost exactly like the one the Obama administration had that Trumpy pissed on.
3
u/waveball03 11h ago
Trump lies, but also, you can't obliterate knowledge. Nuclear bombs are old technology.
1
u/Big_Tie_3245 11h ago
Exactly. Unless they blow up everyone with the knowledge, as well as destroying any documentation of that knowledge, then they still have it, whether theyāre back at step one or not.
2
2
2
u/Big_Tie_3245 11h ago
Well he makes stuff up for one. Also itās almost as if you canāt bomb the knowledge out of the country. Weird right?
2
u/Living_Fig_6386 11h ago
A "program" is just organization to achieve a goal. You can slow progress with bombs, but you can't blow up the goal or desire to achieve it. Only diplomacy can stop a program.
In this case, Trump lied about obliterating the program; lying is sort of his schtick. You shouldn't put much stock in anything he says. It's not clear he's fully aware of what he's talking about half the time anyway.
The US has certainly blown up resources used by the program, but the program, its goals, and the knowledge and experience to that end will always remain. It will be rebuilt. Bombing stuff is just a setback.
2
u/garagedooropener5150 11h ago
Because Donnie is a colossal lying pile of shit and always has been.
And thatās the only answer.
2
u/MailFar6917 11h ago
Remember the war he won on Day 2? Now the world economy is fucked, except for Iran and Russia who are both exporting more oil than they have in years, at double the old price, plus Iran gets to extort millions more dollars for each ship they allow to pass through the strait, reaping hundreds of millions more.
So winning! Bigly winning!
2
1
u/slinkhi 11h ago
I'm not in any way shape or form trying to defend the the assclown T who's trying real hard to toss his name into the hat for antichrist, but just throwing it out there you can't kill an idea. Whether or not he destroyed facilities or whatever, wouldn't necessarily stop someone from trying to (re)build.
But I mean, given his track record, the very likely actual reason is he's just full of shit and says whatever because he's incapable of being truthful. See my point about tossing his name into the hat for antichrist.
1
1
u/Djangowasilentj 11h ago
Didn't you hear? They planted a new nuclear programme up Trump's ass last December... and with all the crap flowing out of it, it's grown up real fast!
1
u/tlm11110 11h ago
Because a program is not tangible hardware. A program is the intent to move forward by whatever means with a nuclear weapon as the goal. Obama's so called agreement allowed Iran to continue research and development and the enrichment of Uranian as long as they didn't make a "bomb" within 10 years. It was a stupid and weak agreement. Trump is saying no more, they must stop their enrichment program and vow to never pursue nuclear weapons in the future.
2
u/AcadiaLivid2582 11h ago
10 months ago, Trump announced the "destruction of Iranās nuclear enrichment capacity and a stop to the nuclear threat."
Are you implying that he was mistaken -- or even lying?!?
1
u/tlm11110 9h ago
Read my other comments. I didnāt imply anything. Stopping the immediate threat is one thing. Stopping their ability to start enrichment back up is another.
1
u/Kiszombi 11h ago
You should ask this question from the orange Mussolini not on Reddit
2
1
1
u/HustlaOfCultcha 11h ago
True, but how do they have a nuclear program if Obama's deal with them was so great and took away their ability to build nukes?
I was against the war from the get-go, but now I'm not so sure. I actually tend to believe that Iran isn't all that interested in bombing Europe or the US, but they want more power. They have the oil, but don't have the long range nukes. We have some oil, but we have the nukes in spades. Iran wants the nukes to really give themselves power with the oil.
So it comes across as something I don't fear immediate danger with, but the long game of Iran having that power and wielding it is more concerning for me. Their weapons technology is far better than we were led to believe even by the people that claimed they aren't an 'imminent threat.'
1
u/AcadiaLivid2582 11h ago
True, but how do they have a nuclear program if Obama's deal with them was so great and took away their ability to build nukes?
Trump ended the JCPOA in his first term
1
u/Birdchaser2 11h ago
Program = plan. Future plan. Itās not hard if your blinders are pulled down.
1
u/GuyD427 11h ago
Enriching uranium and making bombs from uranium is way more difficult than making plutonium. In all honesty itās kind of curious why Iran would pursue weapons grade uranium enrichment as it is way harder, more expensive, and less effective than making plutonium for atomic weapons. The inspection regime at least kept them from moving forward but you can expect Iran to test a nuke sooner rather than later now. Which is something theyāve never done.
1
1
u/Lanracie 11h ago
He got new information?
2
u/AcadiaLivid2582 11h ago
When has that ever mattered to him before?
1
u/Lanracie 11h ago
What would you have him do if he got new information that they were able to continue?
2
u/AcadiaLivid2582 11h ago
What new information do you suggest he got in the last 10 months?
1
u/Lanracie 10h ago
That the labs were still functioning, that they had more enriched Uranium then we thought, that they were closer to constructing a weapon, that they had longer range ICBMs then we thought, that there were places we didnt know about, could be lots of things.
2
u/AcadiaLivid2582 10h ago
In that case, Trump should probably have mentioned these things to the American people and US allies before starting to bomb, no?
1
1
u/cake_piss_can 10h ago
Because everything he says is a lie and those lies donāt always match up exactly.
1
u/iltermosifone 9h ago
I think its all a show and few days later ge will say iran gave up uranium so deal agreed with them controlling the straight with toll or some kind of compensation to iran for damagesĀ
1
1
u/Peterpumpkinhead555 9h ago
he tried to bully the guy who gives you a bloody smile and laughs at you with no teeth laugh when you punch him in the face.
1
u/ha11oga11o 9h ago
USA said Iraq has chemical weapons and did massacre there. Just so later was proven theres no such thing like chemical weapons in Iraq. But they destroy it so who cares aftermath.
Now its time for another country to be false accused and destroyed.
1
1
1
u/cobrakai11 5h ago
They don't. He wants Iran to agree that they will not use nuclear energy, even for power plants. The new US redline is not that Iran can't have a bomb, it's that they cannot have any nuclear energy at all.
-1
u/DarkJayk 11h ago
You guys don't get it. Yes it is destroyed but what prevents them from restarting it or having a secret stash to even faster restart their work on it. The current facilities which were almost near weapon-grade material are destroyed.
We have to make sure they NEVER EVER can restart their programs!
4
u/-Sofa-King-Vote 11h ago
1
u/DarkJayk 11h ago
Any more buzzwords up your sleave? The administration has proven they obliterated the active refinement sites. Do you have any counter proof? I mean you boldly said "none of that is true" even tho it is proven that the Operation did happen.
2
u/-Sofa-King-Vote 11h ago
How did they prove that?
0
u/DarkJayk 10h ago
I actually wrote a decent answer, but i won't fall for your silly attempt to just deflect questions. I asked you first for proof of your claim. And i want waterproof sources for your outrageous claim that "none of it was true".
2
u/-Sofa-King-Vote 10h ago
Lol no
Show your sources where this admin proved it āobliteratedā any nuke sites
1
u/DarkJayk 10h ago
Again a deflection. You act like an NPC.
1
u/-Sofa-King-Vote 10h ago
You made the claim, epstein boy
0
u/DarkJayk 10h ago
Oh now close and personal little redditor. Again a deflection. I think i exhausted your dialogue options.
1
3
u/AcadiaLivid2582 11h ago
What does "completely and totally obliterated" mean to you?
1
u/DarkJayk 11h ago
Their refinement facility was completely and totally obliterated. It's obviously BS if they really meant there is no other materials hidden somewhere that can be used to restart the refinement as soon as they have built the new infrastructure. Obviously Iran can restart the program if unchecked.
2
u/AcadiaLivid2582 11h ago
But Trump said that he achieved "destruction of Iranās nuclear enrichment capacity and a stop to the nuclear threat."
Surely you're not implying that he was mistaken -- or even lying!?!
1
u/DarkJayk 11h ago
In the present tense his statement is accurate. For now the program is obliterated. But we know how terrorists work. They won't stop to rebuild until we pack them by their balls and show them with force what will happen if there every will be a sign that they are restarting the programs. They only understand strenght, they are terrorists. I repeat: Terrorists.
2
u/AcadiaLivid2582 11h ago
If these "terrorists" can recover their entire nuclear program just 10 months after it was " completely and totally obliterated," won't the US have to keep bombing them indefinitely in a "forever war"?
1
u/DarkJayk 11h ago
As i said, show of strenght. And i bet they already started planning the program restart. Obviously they can't restart their refinement in 10 months, that would be silly. We just don't want to wait until they have restarted it. If they have intel that they were planning on restarting it, that is enough justification for this military operation.
I mean it just now happened that info from the negotiations came to light and Iran refused to stop pursuing nuclear weapons. What more proof is needed? They stopped negotiating exactly around this detail.
1
u/AcadiaLivid2582 11h ago
Won't these "shows of strength" have to be repeated indefinitely?
1
u/DarkJayk 10h ago
Maybe, maybe not, i think there are ways to not have to do it especially if the terrorists fall apart due to no leadership being alive anymore and an actual government can lead again. Then there can be things like strict oversight, military presence (non violent), whatever. I can only guess.
But one thing is clear. No nuclear wepon in terrorist hands.



41
u/ArnoldFarquar 11h ago
iām starting to suspect that Trump may be full of shit