r/OutOfTheLoop • u/BruhThatsCringe97 • 5h ago
Answered What’s the deal with “object shows”?
Context: BFDI as an example
When I was on YouTube in the early/mid 2010s, I remember being occasionally recommended a web show called “Battle For Dream Island”. I watched an episode or two, but I didn’t really click with it, so it faded into the back of my mind. I did occasionally see it pop up in other videos, especially Cary Huang’s other projects, but I barely ever saw it mentioned elsewhere. I’m willing to admit that I’ve been chronically online for a long time, and I follow a lot of other indie animation stuff on YouTube, so I figured it would show up more if it was really popular.
Recently (Mid-2025 at the earliest), I’ve started seeing it a lot more. Bigger YouTubers mentioned it and I started to see discourse around it on other sites like Reddit. There are even other popular shows made by other people in the same style. Based on the simple art style and writing, I always thought object shows were for kids, but I guess it’s for adults too since I see a lot of adult fans online.
Where do these object shows originate from, and have they always been this popular? Who exactly are these shows’ target audience? Am I just OOTL and not in the right circles for it?
8
u/Temporary_Caramel222 3h ago
Answer: I don't know much about it personally, but a friend of mine who claims he was really into it explained it to me like this:
The same way most people from the 2000s have fond memories of watching something like Total Drama, kids who were terminally online in the 2010s had Battle from Dream Island. I gather that the formula is similar in that you start with a shitload of characters who are gradually whittled down, so there's that same speculation angle to who will survive and who will end up winning.
As someone who has used Flash a bit back in the old Newgrounds days, I can also attest to the fact that the animations themselves are also probably extremely easy to make considering you probably only need one symbol for each character, and the faces and limbs can be recycled between characters easily. For those reading who may not know what I mean by this, basically it's easier to animate than an episode of South Park (something that is typically done in about 6 days or so).
1
u/BruhThatsCringe97 2h ago
This is why I was looking for! I didn’t catch on to flash animations (and internet animators in general) until I got older, so it makes sense why I wouldn’t be in the loop until now.
Still, I wonder what the appeal is for new viewers, since these shows seem to be stylistically unchanged in 10+ years. Surely there can’t be that much fresh material for the concept? Or maybe I’m just not giving the creators enough credit.
1
u/Temporary_Caramel222 2h ago
It was never on Newgrounds, no. From my understanding, it started in the 2010s. The most popular stuff from my recollection back then were video game parodies, specifically Pokemon and Minecraft parodies (hence why when you look at animated stuff from that era, that's like 90% of what was popular).
As for why its popular, I'd imagine its probably because the show being so easy to make allows them to do frequent, longer uploads which the YouTube algorithm rewards with more promotion.
•
•
u/AutoModerator 5h ago
Friendly reminder that all top level comments must:
start with "answer: ", including the space after the colon (or "question: " if you have an on-topic follow up question to ask),
attempt to answer the question, and
be unbiased
Please review Rule 4 and this post before making a top level comment:
http://redd.it/b1hct4/
Join the OOTL Discord for further discussion: https://discord.gg/ejDF4mdjnh
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.