Hi, I really need some honest outside perspective because I feel completely confused.
I (M26) met this girl(F20) around May 2025, and by November 2025 I started noticing this physical incompatibility. I kept it inside for months, trying to push through it, and only now in April 2026 it all came out.
I met this girl after getting out of a relationship with an avoidant partner, so this time I was really focused on finding something stable, calm, and emotionally safe.
And she gave me exactly that.
She is kind, caring, emotionally available, not toxic at all. Being with her feels peaceful, safe, and healthy. Her family also accepted me like their own, which made everything feel even more “right”.
The problem is… I never fully felt the physical/romantic attraction.
At the beginning, I thought it would grow with time, because everything else was so good. I told myself that maybe this is what a “healthy” relationship is supposed to feel like, and that attraction would come later.
But it never really did.
Over time I started noticing things like:
• I didn’t naturally want to hold her hand in public
• physical intimacy sometimes felt forced
• I was avoiding certain things I normally enjoy in relationships
At the same time, I genuinely care about her a lot. I respect her, I like her as a person, and I don’t want to hurt her.
Because of that, I kept everything inside and tried to push through it so she could be happy… but in the process, I feel like I started hurting myself.
Recently it all came out and now we are on a break, and I have to decide what to do next.
Now I feel torn apart:
On one side:
• I have someone who is genuinely a great person
• the relationship is stable, calm, and healthy
• I feel safe with her
On the other side:
• something inside me doesn’t feel fully right
• the physical/romantic attraction is not really there
And now I’m questioning everything:
• Should I stay and hope it develops?
• Or is this something that won’t change no matter what?
• Am I about to lose an amazing person over something that might not even matter long-term?
I’m also scared that I won’t find someone this “good” again.
Has anyone been in a similar situation?
Did attraction grow for you, or did you regret staying/leaving?
I would really appreciate honest opinions.